Equity compensation planning can be both intricate and rewarding, especially when dealing with a variety of stock options. For those working in startups or companies nearing a liquidity event like an IPO or acquisition, managing incentive stock options (ISOs), non-qualified stock options (NQSOs), and restricted stock units (RSUs) requires careful planning to make informed decisions about tax efficiency. This post outlines key considerations and strategies for navigating these complexities, particularly as major company events approach.
Planning for Equity Compensation Events
When someone joins a startup early, they may receive ISOs as part of their compensation package. ISOs offer potentially favorable tax treatment but come with possible pitfalls, primarily due to the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT). This hidden tax can catch many off guard when they exercise their ISOs, but careful planning can help manage it.
As a company moves closer to a liquidity event, whether through an IPO or acquisition, additional stock options like NQSOs or performance-based options often come into play. At this stage, RSUs may also be introduced, giving employees a clear quantity of shares over a vesting period. The complexity arises when multiple forms of equity are on the table simultaneously. It’s essential to consider how and when each option is exercised, especially in conjunction with an approaching liquidity event.
Inventorying and Forecasting
One of the first steps in managing equity compensation is keeping a comprehensive inventory of all options granted. This should include details like issuance dates, strike prices, current fair market values, and any embedded gains within each option. Alongside this inventory, it’s important to build out detailed tax projections. These projections include all income sources—yours, your spouse’s, and even expected income unrelated to these equity events. You can then layer in your deductions, resulting in a pro forma tax return, often projected out two years or more.
This process becomes particularly important because RSUs typically trigger taxable income at vesting, forcing you to recognize income whether or not you sell the shares. By integrating this forced income event into the projections, you can update the tax model as the market value changes, allowing for adjustments in real time.
Managing Incentive Stock Options
Given the potential tax benefits ISOs can provide—possibly converting what would be ordinary income into long-term capital gains—it’s crucial to determine how much of these options to exercise while staying within AMT thresholds. For some, dipping slightly into AMT territory can unlock AMT credits, which may be useful in future tax years. The goal is often to consider how much of your ISOs you can exercise without triggering significant AMT, while still capturing long-term gain benefits.
If market conditions change and the stock value decreases, strategies like a “tuck-under” exercise allow for filling in any gaps under the AMT exemption. Essentially, this involves gradually exercising more NQSOs to stay within your desired tax profile, which helps keep your overall tax burden as low as possible while evaluating long-term gains.
Incorporating Non-Qualified Stock Options and RSUs
While ISOs offer potentially significant tax advantages, NQSOs and RSUs present their own opportunities and challenges. NQSOs don’t enjoy the same tax treatment as ISOs, and their value must be integrated into your overall strategy. Often, it may be beneficial to focus on NQSOs in later years when ISOs and RSUs have been managed, ensuring the highest after-tax benefit across all equity types.
RSUs, by their nature, often dictate your income levels without giving you much flexibility. However, integrating RSUs into your planning allows for balancing the timing of exercising other options around these events. The objective for many is to identify opportunities to optimize value while considering the tax implications.
The Goal: Maximize Value and Consider Taxes
Ultimately, strategic planning around various equity options often focuses on identifying opportunities to optimize value while considering tax implications. This requires continuous monitoring, adjustments, and a dynamic approach as market conditions and company events unfold. By maintaining an accurate inventory, forecasting tax impacts, and evaluating when to exercise options, you can navigate the complexity of equity compensation to make informed decisions.
–––
Brickley Wealth Management is a Registered Investment Adviser*. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where Brickley Wealth Management and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure. The information throughout this website is solely for informational purposes. The content is developed from sources believed to provide accurate information, and we conduct reasonable due diligence review however, the information contained throughout this website is subject to change without notice and is not free from error. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns. Investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. Readers should conduct their own review and exercise judgment prior to investing and should carefully consider their own investment objectives and not rely on any post, chart, graph or marketing piece to make a decision. No investment or tax advice may be rendered by Brickley Wealth Management or Brickley & Company unless a client service agreement is in place. We are not providing any personalized investment advice through this website. Please consult your investment, tax, or legal advisor for assistance regarding your individual situation. Brickley Wealth Management does not provide legal advice, and nothing in this website shall be construed as legal advice. For more information on our firm and our advisers, please see the latest Form ADV and Part 2 Brochures and our Client Relationship Summary https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/287487. For a copy of our Privacy Notice, please go here.
*Please note that the term "registered investment adviser" and description of our firm and/or our associates as "registered" does not imply a certain level of skill or training.